So, Book 9 was all about Dmitri. We see him being questioned by the investigators in the death of his father. His battle with the investigators is over the circumstantial evidence of his guilt–but it really is a reckoning with how he has lived his life. Every part of the story has burst from the chaos that is the wanton and immoral life that Dmitri has chosen to live. Unlike Dmitry, we cannot help but see: you will reap the fruit of the seeds you sow.
Book Ten is very interesting, in that it seems to have no place in the book. Plot-wise, we were driving forward. Now, 680 pages in, we finally get to the meat of the story–the death of the Karamazov father. What happens in the next Chapter? We pick up a subplot line where no one mentions anything about the murder. Instead, we are at the sick bed of a child, and we learn about the internal politics of teenage bullies in Russia.
There does seem to be a point, though. It’s the power of contrast. We see how Dmitri was living his life. In this section, we see the type of man Aloysha is. He’s all the whiter for the darkness of Book 9.
Aloysha has been organizing the children to visit the sick child every day. He has accompanied them as well. He has also successfully encouraged one particular young man to make his first visit. There is a heartwarming scene with a canine reunion. Aloysha is a veritable Father Flanagan to these young men. They note that he doesn’t talk down to them or insult them.
Not to put too fine a point on it but Dmitri spends his time stealing 3,000 roubles to chase Grushenka and plying the peasants with food and wine, while Aloysha was taking teenage miscreants to the sickbed of an ailing/dying child.
I assume that we have the big trial coming up next, which promises more of the dark side of the story and the family. I think Doestevsky wanted to take a second before that starts to show that alternate paths do exist, even people who are cursed with the same genes and the same family.